Smith & Wesson 442 Review: The Best Hammerless .38 Snubnose That Money Can Buy?

Table of Contents

The .38 snubnose still matters.

It’s the kind of gun that makes sense in just about any situation. You can slip it into a pocket before heading out the door, tuck it under a poker table while holding a losing hand, use it as a backup gun to a semi-automatic with more capacity, or keep it in the truck safe when you’re gonna be hitting the road. 

The snubnose doesn’t care about style points, and it’s not chasing trends. It’s simple, and it’s reliable, and when you pull the trigger, it fires. 

That’s all a person really needs.

Now, I’ve owned my share of little semi-auto pocket semi-automatic pistols, like those tiny little .380s that promise convenience but that sometimes end up being more trouble than they’re worth. Sure, they’re slim and easy to carry, but anyone who has put enough rounds through them knows that little guns have a greater tendency to jam. They’re just picky about ammo. And when you’re relying on a pocket pistol for defense, the last thing you want to worry about is whether the next round will actually chamber. 

The Smith & Wesson 442 is one of the best hammerless .38 snubnose revolvers that money can buy today. Alternatively, you can get the silver stainless variant, which is called the 642 but is otherwise identical.

After enough frustration, I finally said to myself, “Forget it. I’m going back to the revolver.”

The .38 snubnose never jams. Ever. That reliability alone is worth the trade-off of a smaller capacity and slower reloads. Yes, you only get five shots, but they’re five for sure shots. AND When things get close and personal, five rounds of .38 Special from a snubby SHOULD do the trick.

The “Get Off Me” Gun

The snubnose revolver is what I like to call a “get off me” gun. It’s not designed to be flashy. It’s not designed for long-range precision shooting or showing off at the range. 

It’s designed for one thing: saving your hide when danger is breathing down your neck. 

Pull it out, point it at the threat, and squeeze. That’s it.

Reloading is not lightning fast, and it’s true that five rounds can disappear quicker than you’d like. But let’s be honest: in most real-world defensive scenarios, five rounds is enough. 

Anybody Can Shoot It

One of the best things about a revolver is its simplicity. I could hand my snubnose to someone who has never shot a firearm in their life, and they’d figure it out in seconds. No safeties to mess with, no slides to rack, no worries about limp-wristing the grip. 

Just pull the trigger. That’s it.

That simplicity also makes it a perfect gun to share in a defensive scenario. If I’m carrying my Beretta M9 or Sig M11 as my main piece and things get hairy, I can hand the snubnose to a buddy or family member, and they’ll have no trouble running it. 

The S&W 442 may only hold 5 shots of .38 Special, but it’s five for sure shots.

Compare that to trying to teach someone under pressure not to put their thumb behind a semi-auto slide. That’s a recipe for bloody thumbs and frustration. The snubnose cuts all that out.

Enter the Smith & Wesson 442

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the Smith & Wesson 442. This revolver (along with its silver stainless counterpart, the 642) has earned its reputation as one of the best concealed carry snubbies around, and for good reason.

Smith & Wesson has been cranking out J-frame revolvers for decades, and they’ve pretty much perfected the formula. The 442 is their hammerless, double-action-only model, which means there’s nothing to snag when pulling it out of a pocket or holster. It’s lightweight, simple, and built for everyday carry.

Sure, there are other options. The Model 36 or 637, for instance, if you prefer an exposed hammer. Colt, Taurus, and Ruger all make their own takes on the snubnose too. But when it comes to refinement, heritage, and overall quality, the Smith & Wesson J-frame is hard to beat.

Compared to Taurus, the Smith feels a little more polished. Compared to Colt, it’s far more affordable. And compared to Ruger’s LCR, I like the metal frame better. Now, don’t get me wrong, Ruger makes some fantastic revolvers. I’ve got a GP100, and it’s one of my favorites. But for a true snubnose carry revolver, Smith & Wesson just has the edge.

The Lock-Free 442

Here’s something I really appreciate about the 442 I picked up: no internal lock. Most modern Smith & Wesson revolvers have that little keyhole lock that gun folks either ignore or hate. 

I fall into the latter category. I didn’t want one. I specifically went to the sporting goods store and asked for the lock-free model.

Why does it matter? Well, the lock has been known (rarely, but still) to cause issues, and it just adds a layer of complexity to a gun that’s supposed to be as simple as possible. 

Notice how there is no safety lock above the cylinder release on this 442. 

When I grab my revolver in the middle of the night or if I have to whip it out of my pocket, I want absolute confidence that nothing is going to stand in the way of those five rounds doing their job. The 442 without the lock gives me that confidence.

Always Legal, Always Handy

Another huge advantage of the snubnose revolver is how universally legal it is. Semi-auto pistols can sometimes run into restrictions depending on what state you’re in. Magazine limits, safety requirements, you name it. 

But the humble .38 revolver just slides right on through.

That’s why mine lives in my Ford truck most of the time, where it’s tucked inside a safe mounted to the side. No matter where I’m headed on a road trip, I know I’ll be legal with the snubnose. Add in a Galco leather pocket holster and a 5-shot speedloader, and it’s a compact little package that’s easy to keep close to me. 

The Backup Role

As much as I love carrying the snubnose on its own, it also shines as a backup gun. When I’m carrying a full-size pistol like my 1911 or M9 or M11, the .38 sometimes slips right into my pocket as a secondary option.

Why is it so good in that role? First, the size. It’s small and lightweight, so it doesn’t weigh me down or get in the way. 

Second, the reliability. If something were to go wrong with my primary firearm, I know the snubnose will be ready. 

And third, like I mentioned earlier, I can hand it to someone else if the situation calls for it.

Most people have no idea how often inexperienced shooters get tripped up with semi-autos. They limp-wrist the gun and then it stovepipes. They grip it wrong and end up with a nasty cut from the slide. 

With a revolver, none of that matters. Hand it over, say “point and shoot,” and they’re good to go. That peace of mind makes it a great companion gun.

On the Range and On the Road

Now, let’s be honest: shooting a snubnose revolver at the range isn’t quite the same as shooting a full-size pistol. 

That short barrel, light frame, and stiff trigger pull make it a little less fun to plink with for long sessions. 

But that’s not what it’s for, either. You don’t take a snubnose to the range to make tight groups at 25 yards. You take it to make sure you can consistently hit center mass at seven feet. That’s its bread and butter.

The 442 is perfectly at home and can be carried anywhere in a Galco pocket IWB holster. 

Out on the road, though, that’s where it really earns its keep. Regardless of whether it’s stashed in the truck safe or riding in a pocket holster, it’s there if I need it. 

And because it’s so simple, I never have to second-guess whether it’s going to fire.

A Timeless Concealed Carry Choice

The .38 snubnose revolver has been a concealed carry favorite for generations, and it still holds its own today. 

The Smith & Wesson 442 in particular is a prime example of why. Sure, it doesn’t pack the same capacity as a double-stack 9mm, and it’s not going to win any beauty contests at the gun range. 

But what it does offer is more important. It’s a casual gun, the kind you grab when you don’t want to think too hard. It’s the one you know will work when you need it most. 

The 442 is that gun. It may not be flashy, but it’s dependable. It may not hold 17 rounds, but it only needs five. 

And when it comes down to it, that might just make it the best hammerless .38 snubnose money can buy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *